Page MenuHomeFeedback Tracker

Millions of Fake Players in DayZ: Online Inflation and Chaos in the Server List
Feedback, NormalPublic

Description

Hello, dear developers of DayZ!

I recently developed server analytics, available on https://ts4ta.com, and discovered some surprising results. According to Steam, the current online player count is about 55,000. However, analyzing the server data reveals entirely different numbers:

  • 1,014,605 bots.
  • 303,213 artificially inflated players (not bots).
  • 224,688 players waiting in server queues.

In total, this adds up to over 1.5 million "players", which is far beyond the official statistics shown on Steam.

Here are a few questions:

  1. How is it possible that the number of "players" visible in the launcher and on servers exceeds the official Steam data so drastically?
  2. What is your stance on the current issue of player count inflation on community servers? Based on my analysis, over 5,000 servers are manipulating their numbers, with a significant portion of players ending up on such servers.
  3. How are players expected to find quality servers to play on when:
    • Official servers are often plagued by cheaters and performance issues?
    • Community servers heavily inflate their player counts?
  4. Why not implement a filtering and verification system in the launcher to exclude servers that engage in these practices? It seems like a straightforward step that could greatly improve the quality of the game and user experience.

I'm not a professional programmer, but I managed to create an analytics prototype in just a few evenings, which uncovered this massive issue. While my calculations might not be perfect (the real player count might be even higher when adjusted for inflation), it’s clear that the problem with artificial inflation is critical. Players deserve a better approach to server management.

Can you comment on this situation and share any plans to improve the launcher and combat the manipulation of player counts?

Thank you in advance for your response!

Details

Severity
Major
Resolution
Open
Reproducibility
Always
Operating System
Windows 7
Category
General
Steps To Reproduce

This happens constantly. I believe many players have noticed servers showing 255/255 players.

Additional Information

I’ve been collecting this data for a long time. It’s disheartening to see this issue persist, to the point where I lost interest in playing. However, I finally found time to publicly ask you about this.

Event Timeline

This is something we had to deal with alot (as server owners and players).
There are a few known servers that do inflate player count artificially and they end up at the top when searching for servers because they got the most players which is extremely unfair for legit servers that might actually bring or would bring value to the players.

Please look into this BI devs <3

Geez changed the task status from New to Feedback.Tue, Nov 26, 10:55 AM

BI, if you are really interested in fixing this problem, I think you know what to do.
If you want, write me an email, I will share my observations, it will not force you to change the whole system, it will just allow you to calculate the level of trust in the server.

BGZ added a subscriber: BGZ.EditedWed, Nov 27, 1:00 PM

Ffs.. Where is the problem to implement the server list fetching logic in a same/similar way DZSA did?
They are crawling servers from the Steam API (https://api.steampowered.com/IGameServersService/GetServerList/v1/) which cannot be spoofed that easily as direct A2S queries.

You guys (BI devs) have implemented pretty solid solution for the official server verification with a pub/private keys, but you can't fix community servers list? ... Bullshit, I don't believe in that, you just don't give a sh** about this issue and that's it.

This comment was removed by chocopos.


BTW Chocopos is one of the people that did that for god knows how long, he had namalsk servers with fake playercount! Before he took down his servers he begged for donations via ingame messages!
Talking about irony! You think you can remove your comment but i still have it! You should be ashamed of yourself chocopos, because you are part of this problem!!!

BGZ added a comment.Thu, Nov 28, 5:39 PM

Well, sad story. Looks like this ticket/task will be forgotten and buried as 999x other such tickets related to the launcher.
And as usual, it's just a "Feedback" for BI rather than real problem..

NO ONE CARES LOL