Community server - Sakhal very poor server FPS
Reviewed, NormalPublic
Actions

Description

Hello there!
For over an year i run on Host Havoc heavely modded server on Deer Isle map, after DZ 1.26 it still holds 25k FPS empty and 6-10k FPS with 10+ players. 2 days ago i started another server with map Sakhal, only few QoL mods (CF, earplugs, global chat, server info panel, vpp admin tools) and except those mods its completely vanilla settings, also i tried run the server without mods, same result. When is server empty it runs on 2-5k FPS only, when i had only 6 players online we hit <10 FPS and few times even 0 (sadly deleted the logs). Im whole day testing it on my local dev server which runs my heavely modded Deer Isle on 30k+ FPS (storage copied from hosted), while Sakhal runs around 5-9k FPS and i also tried Chernarus which jumps from 3-9k FPS. I cant see any problem in the logs expect few search overtimes which i already fixed, i also saw post here about broken CE and i dont see any items with CE logs enabled that spawns over the limits (hopefuly im not blind). All xml and json files should be valid, checked with 3 IDEs (netbeans, eclipse, vscode).

My local dev server: Ryzen 5800X, 32GB RAM, nvme m2 ssd
On Sakhal server nominal items count: ~12243

Here is completely vanilla Sakhal on local server 0 players:

21:03:25.111 Average server FPS: 6444.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
21:03:26.111 Average server FPS: 9858.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
21:03:27.111 Average server FPS: 7029.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
21:03:28.111 Average server FPS: 7379.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
21:03:29.111 Average server FPS: 9391.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
21:03:30.111 Average server FPS: 9071.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
21:03:31.111 Average server FPS: 5126.00 (measured interval: 1 s)

Here is Sakhal on hosted server with 0 players:

14:40:10.877 Average server FPS: 2165.20 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:15.876 Average server FPS: 5007.60 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:20.876 Average server FPS: 2369.40 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:30.877 Average server FPS: 3402.20 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:35.876 Average server FPS: 2677.80 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:40.877 Average server FPS: 1009.00 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:45.877 Average server FPS: 2274.80 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:50.876 Average server FPS: 2285.60 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:40:55.877 Average server FPS: 3327.93 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:41:00.877 Average server FPS: 2222.00 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:41:05.877 Average server FPS: 3881.00 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:41:10.878 Average server FPS: 1978.40 (measured interval: 5 s)
14:41:15.877 Average server FPS: 1666.80 (measured interval: 5 s)

Here is Sakhal on hosted server with 5 players:

17:17:57.203 Average server FPS: 2.60 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:02.227 Average server FPS: 16.12 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:07.240 Average server FPS: 23.74 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:17.380 Average server FPS: 48.79 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:22.390 Average server FPS: 63.07 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:27.398 Average server FPS: 75.09 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:32.435 Average server FPS: 45.45 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:37.485 Average server FPS: 35.45 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:42.864 Average server FPS: 4.65 (measured interval: 5 s)
17:18:47.864 Average server FPS: 17.60 (measured interval: 5 s)

Here is completely vanilla Chernarus on local server 0 players:

23:01:34.990 Average server FPS: 3764.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:35.989 Average server FPS: 4666.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:36.989 Average server FPS: 4830.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:37.990 Average server FPS: 3366.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:38.990 Average server FPS: 7592.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:39.989 Average server FPS: 9904.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:40.990 Average server FPS: 6411.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:41.990 Average server FPS: 6020.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:42.989 Average server FPS: 5327.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:43.990 Average server FPS: 7169.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:44.989 Average server FPS: 3688.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:45.989 Average server FPS: 6880.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:46.989 Average server FPS: 7382.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:47.989 Average server FPS: 5129.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:01:48.989 Average server FPS: 3242.00 (measured interval: 1 s)

For comparison my heavely modded Deer Isle on local server 0 players:

23:31:16.162 Average server FPS: 28608.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:17.162 Average server FPS: 30449.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:18.162 Average server FPS: 29812.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:19.162 Average server FPS: 30300.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:20.162 Average server FPS: 31345.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:21.163 Average server FPS: 31514.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:22.162 Average server FPS: 31809.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:23.162 Average server FPS: 31952.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:24.162 Average server FPS: 30457.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
23:31:25.163 Average server FPS: 31276.00 (measured interval: 1 s)

Details

Severity: Major
Resolution: Open
Reproducibility: Always
Operating System: Windows 10 x64
Category: Server

Steps To Reproduce

Download DZ server from steam.
Turn on log server fps in config
Run the server with map Chernarus or Sakhal

Event Timeline

Chimere created this task.Oct 17 2024, 11:47 PM

Chimere updated the task description. (Show Details)Oct 17 2024, 11:52 PM

Right now only 1 player online - Host Havoc server:

19:57:53.905 Players: 1 in total
19:57:56.982 Average server FPS: 288.85 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:01.982 Average server FPS: 234.80 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:03.906 Players: 1 in total
19:58:06.982 Average server FPS: 264.40 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:11.983 Average server FPS: 249.15 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:13.907 Players: 1 in total
19:58:16.983 Average server FPS: 270.80 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:21.988 Average server FPS: 269.78 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:23.907 Players: 1 in total
19:58:26.988 Average server FPS: 283.14 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:31.989 Average server FPS: 239.80 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:33.908 Players: 1 in total
19:58:36.989 Average server FPS: 242.20 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:41.989 Average server FPS: 272.15 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:43.911 Players: 1 in total
19:58:46.990 Average server FPS: 244.75 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:49.253 Used memory: 2523186 KB
19:58:51.991 Average server FPS: 251.95 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:58:53.919 Players: 1 in total
19:58:56.992 Average server FPS: 267.95 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:01.992 Average server FPS: 219.40 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:03.920 Players: 1 in total
19:59:06.994 Average server FPS: 254.50 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:12.04 Average server FPS: 260.28 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:13.920 Players: 1 in total
19:59:17.08 Average server FPS: 216.43 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:22.10 Average server FPS: 100.78 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:23.994 Players: 1 in total
19:59:27.10 Average server FPS: 144.97 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:32.10 Average server FPS: 223.80 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:33.994 Players: 1 in total
19:59:37.10 Average server FPS: 260.15 (measured interval: 5 s)
19:59:42.16 Average server FPS: 275.87 (measured interval: 5 s)

did you try to set power settings to max power? some times it really helps in windows ;)

In T185488#2686650, @endreu wrote:

did you try to set power settings to max power? some times it really helps in windows ;)

my PC isnt the problem, ofc i have power management on max, i posted results from my local PC (dev server, my controlled environment) for comparison with hosted server and also, that heavely modded map has 30k+ FPS while completely vanilla map has poor ~5k, BUT main issue is still extremely poor server FPS on hosted server

sakhal with 0 players

2:10:28 Average server FPS: 3203.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:28 Players: 0 in total
2:10:29 Average server FPS: 3564.74 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:29 Players: 0 in total
2:10:30 Average server FPS: 4437.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:30 Players: 0 in total
2:10:31 Average server FPS: 6163.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:31 Players: 0 in total
2:10:32 Average server FPS: 6513.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:32 Players: 0 in total
2:10:33 Average server FPS: 5235.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:33 Players: 0 in total
2:10:34 Average server FPS: 5555.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:34 Players: 0 in total
2:10:35 Average server FPS: 4394.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:35 Players: 0 in total
2:10:36 Average server FPS: 3689.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:36 Players: 0 in total
2:10:37 Average server FPS: 3063.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:37 Players: 0 in total
2:10:38 Average server FPS: 2514.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:38 Players: 0 in total
2:10:39 Average server FPS: 3429.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:39 Players: 0 in total
2:10:40 Average server FPS: 1139.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:40 Players: 0 in total
2:10:41 Average server FPS: 3256.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:41 Players: 0 in total
2:10:42 Average server FPS: 3597.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:42 Players: 0 in total
2:10:43 Average server FPS: 2811.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:43 Players: 0 in total
2:10:44 Average server FPS: 5099.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:10:44 Players: 0 in total

same map with 1 player

2:16:37 Average server FPS: 5377.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:37 Players: 1 in total
2:16:38 Average server FPS: 5397.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:38 Players: 1 in total
2:16:39 Average server FPS: 5410.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:39 Players: 1 in total
2:16:40 Average server FPS: 5364.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:40 Players: 1 in total
2:16:41 Average server FPS: 5252.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:41 Players: 1 in total
2:16:42 Average server FPS: 5328.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:42 Players: 1 in total
2:16:43 Average server FPS: 5348.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:43 Players: 1 in total
2:16:44 Average server FPS: 5372.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:44 Players: 1 in total
2:16:45 Average server FPS: 5286.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:45 Players: 1 in total
2:16:46 Average server FPS: 5301.00 (measured interval: 1 s)
2:16:46 Players: 1 in total

Vanilla servers shows a bit less fps than Chernarus/Livonia, most likely it's due to insane amount of object on the map, and keep in mind that vanilla consider to be lightest possible, add custom (mostly not optimized) mods to community server, one on top of another... If Livonia/Cherno could forgive that, I doubt Sakhal will. But this is only my thoughts, may be that the issue is elswhere

In T185488#2687214, @MilesDownshur wrote:

Vanilla servers shows a bit less fps than Chernarus/Livonia, most likely it's due to insane amount of object on the map, and keep in mind that vanilla consider to be lightest possible, add custom (mostly not optimized) mods to community server, one on top of another... If Livonia/Cherno could forgive that, I doubt Sakhal will. But this is only my thoughts, may be that the issue is elswhere

hello, you probably didnt read my whole report, even completely vanilla (it means no mods) cherno, livonia and sakhal runs really poor after 1.26 update while my heavely modded server on custom map has 6-10 times more FPS, i know what mods can do, but this seems to be problem with 1.26 itself or bad version of DayZ Server is published on steam

Sakhal on hosted server 0 players, 2 hours from last restart:

21:53:19.301 Average server FPS: 132.94 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:22.261 Players: 0 in total
21:53:24.377 Average server FPS: 10.44 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:29.571 Average server FPS: 19.64 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:32.306 Players: 0 in total
21:53:34.594 Average server FPS: 149.11 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:39.603 Average server FPS: 276.45 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:42.388 Players: 0 in total
21:53:44.609 Average server FPS: 231.72 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:49.692 Average server FPS: 450.91 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:52.401 Players: 0 in total
21:53:54.696 Average server FPS: 40.58 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:53:58.493 Used memory: 2323768 KB
21:53:59.750 Average server FPS: 27.70 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:02.407 Players: 0 in total
21:54:04.803 Average server FPS: 70.67 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:09.803 Average server FPS: 328.33 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:12.407 Players: 0 in total
21:54:14.812 Average server FPS: 275.10 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:19.852 Average server FPS: 281.35 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:22.487 Players: 0 in total
21:54:24.862 Average server FPS: 296.87 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:30.87 Average server FPS: 70.23 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:32.493 Players: 0 in total
21:54:35.88 Average server FPS: 90.16 (measured interval: 5 s)
21:54:40.150 Average server FPS: 77.06 (measured interval: 5 s)

Geez changed the task status from New to Reviewed.Oct 21 2024, 1:13 PM

Geez added a subscriber: Geez.

Community server - Sakhal very poor server FPSReviewed, NormalPublicActions

Description

Details

Event Timeline

Community server - Sakhal very poor server FPS
Reviewed, NormalPublic
Actions