Current version is using low resolution textures (1024x1024) and is extremely reflective, something that was possibly done to match the lighting for pre-alpha era. A more matte look better for the current era.

Vanilla

Upscaled and Tweaked

In my opinion this would make the item more attractive to pick up while still keeping a slight sheen to keep in spirit with the original.

ALSO this item should be 4,4 instead of 5,5 in size.