Page MenuHomeFeedback Tracker

Commander of M41 Bulldog cannot use binoculars/weapon
Closed, ResolvedPublic

Description

When playing as the commander of an M41 Bulldog, especially when in first-person only, it can be difficult to operate the tank since when you open the hatch to let yourself out, instead of being able to take out your binoculars/fire your weapon (like pretty much every other tank in the base game), you end up stuck manning the M2 Browning.
This is really annoying since a tank commander needs to peak out of the tank to scout and designate targets with the binoculars for example.
The use of the M2 Browning should be an option, not something mandatory as it is now (and it's not very realistic), it breaks the tank gameplay when you want to play realistically.

Details

Severity
Feature
Resolution
Open
Reproducibility
Always
Operating System
Windows 10 x64
Operating System Version
10.0.19042 Build 19042
Category
Firing from Vehicles
Steps To Reproduce
  • Get into the editor of any map
  • Place a M41 Bulldog and play as the commander role
  • Play
  • Open the hatch to let yourself out
  • You will use the M2 Browning but will not be able to really act as a tank commander and take your binos for scouting for example

Event Timeline

Zirfly created this task.May 22 2021, 11:37 AM

And by the way it's the same for the Type 63...

Maarten added a subscriber: Maarten.

Thank you for your feedback! It will now be reviewed by a specialist in our internal QA system.

Maarten closed this task as Resolved.Jul 31 2021, 11:44 AM
Maarten claimed this task.

Vehicle Encoder Apollo replied the following:

//This was an initial design decision.

There are no FFV options for players on weapon stations in vanilla, so it is not a feature of the standard game.
Technically it is possible to do, as shown by GM cdlc and some mods, but it requires relatively complex scripting solutions which are not without their own issues in certain circumstances. Made more complicated on tanks, because these player positions are themselves within rotating main turrets.

In the case of the Walker Bulldog, the Commander already has very good visibility when turned-in, via the 360 deg view ports and a dedicated (limited turn) periscope with zoom aligned with the main gun to aid the gunner. When turned out and manning the M2, he can still use free-look to see all around and has 'zoom' on his view.//

We may look into it again in the future but it's currently not very high on the priority list.

Best Regards,
Maarten